Plan section
Objectives of this experiment
Materials needed
procedure experience
1. Casting Read instructions and
2. The game
3. Possible variants
Results, interpretation and discussion
Appendices
Objectives of this experiment
This is an educational experience in competitive markets for goods. It is part of the program first ES (September 2011) (Part 3 "Coordination by the market," Subpart 3.2 "How can a competitive market works there?) And in the second program (retracted 2010) (Section 3.1 "How are prices in a market?").
A market is a meeting point between supply and demand that leads to the formation of a prize. Key institution in a market economy, the market remains discussed in the abstract economic theory, in particular by recourse to models of perfect competition and homo economicus. However, it is often difficult to reach a reasoning on the functioning of a market where the concepts necessary for this reasoning are introduced starting from the abstract representation of economic theory. Participate meaningfully to market transactions can, however simpler to facilitate access to the study of market coordination.
In this educational experience, some students are sellers of a property where they know the cost of production. The other students are buyers of the property where they know the value for themselves. Each vendor must look for a buyer with whom he will agree on a price for the exchange and, conversely, every buyer seller should seek to conclude a transaction. The gains made by students depend on the price they can sell (for sellers) or buy (for buyers) property. If sellers offer prices too high or if buyers offer prices too low, the total gains made by all pupils will be low and the market does not therefore result in effective coordination.
This experiment is interesting. It allows the introduction, from a direct contact with the market, the problems of negotiation and coordination, the question of price formation, the law of supply and demand. The construction of curves of supply and demand as well as understanding the concept of equilibrium are facilitated. Feature, can also draw on this experience to introduce the concept of efficiency, making them easily introduce the concepts of surplus from the seller, the buyer of surplus and social surplus.
Materials needed
- A set of 54 playing cards without figures or wildcards. It will take 1 card per student.
- instructions and the results sheet given in Annex 1. Must reproduce these documents in as many copies as there are students.
procedure experience
1. Casting and Reading instructions
The teacher is 1 or 2 assistants who will be responsible to note that the prices negotiated in the table and announce loudly to market participants. The number of assistants should be chosen so that the remaining students (those who will negotiate on the market) are an even number. These remaining pupils are separated into 2 groups of equal size: the students left the teacher will be the sellers and the right of students to teachers will be buyers.
Distribution instructions and score sheets to students.
The teacher reads the directions of the market game of a property given in the appendix. He then answered questions and ensures that each student has understood the rules of the game
2. The game
The teacher distributes a red card to each buyer and a black card each vendor. For 32 students, the teacher has previously kept such as hearts and tiles numbered from 3 to 10 and spades and clovers numbered 1-8.
Once the cards have been distributed, the teacher opens the first trading period: he invites sellers and buyers to steer toward the center of the classroom to begin negotiations, and states that students have 5 minutes from this moment. As
as pairs of buyers and sellers come to the office to register their transaction, the teacher or assistant checks the validity of the negotiated price (no less than the cost to the seller or price above the value for the buyer), to collect maps of buyers and sellers who have concluded a valid transaction, ask them to return to their places and remain there until the end of the period, scored the best prices on the board and announces the price out loud.
After 5 minutes of the period, the teacher announces the closure of the market. He picks up the cards of the students were unable to reach a settlement. It encourages students to calculate their earnings while beating all red cards and all cards black.
A new distribution of cards and then place a new trading period 5 minutes to order.
The total number of periods will be 4 to 7 depending on the time available to the teacher.
3. Possible variants
It is possible to introduce supply shocks or demand by changing from one period to the other production costs of sellers or buyers of securities. For example, a € 2 tax borne by all sellers from the 5 th period uniformly increase the production costs of 2 €.
Results, interpretation and discussion
Production costs of sellers and buyers determine the values of the curves of supply and demand in the market and the prices and amount of competitive balance (see illustration: Appendices 2 and 3). Negotiations students almost always lead to a convergence towards this award and the amount of balance, this convergence is more pronounced in As the repetition periods of trade. The law of supply and demand is true then, and prices are fulfilling their informative role.
The convergence to equilibrium competitive also maximizes the sum of the earnings of participants in the exchange and ensures the effectiveness of coordination.
Ways to engage in discussions with students are many.
can directly from the observation series of negotiated prices and ask them to reflect on the reasons for convergence towards a single price.
can also reveal the production costs of sellers and buyers' values. This information, which were deprived during the experiment, can lead students to understand graphically the construction of curves of supply and demand. Thus they discovered that the price to which convergence has occurred is the meeting point of two curves.
discussion can continue on the relevance of the law of supply and demand in the event of market complex, the reasons for price flexibility may be questioned ... etc..
Appendices
The photovoltaic panels will be of two kinds of membranes amorphous rock dust (picture above) on the greater part of the roof and polycrystalline panels on the roof park that buyers of 1100 m² is completely new (technical explanation will be given in the next few posts on this blog).
Explanations to the park buyers